Blargh, that must be the other chunk of Play Pirates (there's two bits to that interaction, one bans them from going on the ship to play, one bans them from asking each other. I successfully banned going on the ship, but not ASKING to go on the ship, that gave me errors too. I salute Inge for managing to mod it). Best to chuck that one entirely, then.

I'm not sure what's going on with Dirty Joke and Red Hands. Even if there were a conflict, you should be getting issues like either the ban object doesn't work or you're getting AGS behavior instead of religious behavior. What does the HCDU say now?